Jovany Barreto, who showed off his abs to Jennifer Lopez in his first audition, gave his best with a performance of Edwin McCain’s “I’ll Be” at the American Idol season 10 Top 12 Guys semifinal on Tuesday (March 1)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol 10 SPOILERS: Top 24 Revealed (PHOTOS)

Was that enough? Steven Tyler exclaimed, “Holy shipyard!” WHAT? JLo was very pleased with his performance. And Randy Jackson finally disagreed, saying it was “very karaoke”. Yeah, Jovany was kind of good and if he meant to put us to sleep, he almost succeeded.

2011 American Idol 10 SPOILERS: 13 Finalists

Jovany is one of the contestants I never understood how they got so far. And here he is to prove that he is an OK singer, but his performance wasn’t in any way extraordinary. He’s OUT. Simon Cowell would have ripped Jovany a new one for that lame performance.

Jovany Barreto “I’ll Be” American Idol Video

[image: Michael Becker/FOX]