Haley Reinhart performed a rendition of Alicia Keys’ “Fallin’”, the song from her first audition in Milwaukee, at the American Idol season 10 Top 12 Girls semifinal on Wednesday (March 2)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10: Top 24 Revealed (PHOTOS)

Steven Tyler said Haley delivered the right amount of style and sexy. Jennifer Lopez claimed she showed them a lot of different things she can do with her voice and declared Haley deserves to be there. Randy Jackson was shocked – he didn’t like it at all, calling it a karaoke performance. That was harsh.

2011 American Idol 10 SPOILERS: 13 Finalists

There is a lot of soul and flavor in Haley. There’s no singer like her in the competition. The question is: can she evolve or is this it? I’d vote for Haley to stay.

Haley Reinhart “Fallin’” American Idol Video

[image: Michael Becker/FOX]