Julie Zorrilla made the mistake of performing a rendition of “Breakaway” by THE Idol winner Kelly Clarkson at the American Idol season 10 Top 12 Girls semifinal on Wednesday (March 2)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10: Top 24 Revealed (PHOTOS)

Oh. No. Steven Tyler told Julie that was a wrong song choice for her! Jennifer Lopez was disappointed, but claimed Julie was more connected to the song this time. Randy Jackson said she brought nothing new, didn’t sing well and just paled in comparison to Kelly Clarkson.

2011 American Idol 10 SPOILERS: 13 Finalists

HUGE mistake! Julie had some fabulous moments during the auditions, but she blew it. Julie is most probably out of the Idol stage for good. This is sad…

Julie Zorrilla “Breakaway” American Idol Video

[image: Michael Becker/FOX]