Paul McDonald chose the sing “I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues” by Elton John (1984) at the American Idol season 10 Top 12 live show dedicated to songs from the contestants’ birth year on Wednesday (March 16)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10 Top 13 Finalists Revealed!

Steven Tyler said Paul defines “a cool dude in a loose mood” (whatever that means!). Jennifer Lopez praised him for his style, soul and star quality. Randy Jackson thought it was a bit pitchy and ordered him to get the notes right.

You heard the Dawg. Paul was sick. I expected more from Paul, but his raspy voice and incredible attitude on stage totally made up for some pitchiness here and there. Paul really enjoys being on stage and performing for an audience. Love it.

Paul McDonald “I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues” American Idol Top 12 Video

More American Idol Season 10 Top 12 Performances
Naima Adedapo “What’s Love Got To Do With It” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Paul McDonald “I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Thia Megia “Colors Of The Wind” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
James Durbin “I’ll Be There For You” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “I’m Your Baby Tonight” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Stefano Langone “If You Don’t Know Me By Now” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Pia Toscano “Where Do Broken Hearts Go” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “Can I Trust You With My Heart” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Karen Rodriguez “Love Will Lead You Back” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Casey Abrams “Smells Like Teen Spirit” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “I’m The Only One” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)
Jacob Lusk “Alone” American Idol Top 12 (VIDEO)

[image: Ray Mickshaw / FOX]