Haley Reinhart performed Blondie’s hit “Call Me” from “First Monday In October” soundtrack at the American Idol season 10 Top 8 live show dedicated to songs from the movies on Wednesday (April 13)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10 Top 13 Finalists (Bios, Photos)

Oh. No. Randy Jackson didn’t love it and thought it sounded very karaoke and didn’t showcase Haley’s voice. Steven Tyler agreed, but said she nailed the chorus and some songs are all about the chorus. Jennifer Lopez also thought it was not impressive, but she doesn’t want to lose another girl.

Wonder why there are no girls left? That is why. Other contestants deserved the same or more criticism than Haley was subjected to… that didn’t happen! For some reason the judges seemed afraid to say a word other then you are great to Lauren Alaina, Scotty McCreery or even Paul McDonald.

Haley Reinhart “Call Me” American Idol Top 8 Video

American Idol Season 10 Top 8 Movie Night Performances
Paul McDonald “Old Time Rock and Roll” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “The Climb” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Stefano Langone “End Of The Road” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “I Cross My Heart” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Casey Abrams “Nature Boy” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “Call Me” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
Jacob Lusk “Bridge Over Troubled Water” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)
James Durbin “Heavy Metal” American Idol Top 8 (VIDEO)

[image: Michael Becker / FOX]