Haley Reinhart dared to sing an unreleased song, “You and I”, by eccentric singer Lady GaGa at the American Idol season 10 Top 5 live show dedicated to songs from now and then on Wednesday (May 4)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10 Top 13 Finalists (Bios, Photos)

Steven Tyler said it was just beautiful. Jennifer Lopez said she loved the way Haley sounded, but thought it wasn’t a good idea to sing an unreleased track. Randy Jackson said it’s too risky to sing something nobody knows and that it didn’t really favored Haley.

Nonsense. I LOVED IT! I know that song! And most GaGa fans or anyone that has been in one of GaGa’s concert know it and love it. GaGa has been on tour forever. Besides some songs sang on Idol, some people might have never heard and still like how the contestants sing it. I can’t believe the judges totally forgot to comment on the most important thing – Haley killed it! She rocked it!!

Haley Reinhart “You and I” American Idol Top 5 Video

American Idol Top 5 Now and Then Performances
James Durbin “Closer To The Edge” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Jacob Lusk “No Air” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “Flat On The Floor” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “Gone” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “You and I” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
James Durbin “Without You” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Jacob Lusk “Love Hurts” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “Unchained Melody” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “Always On My Mind” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “House Of The Rising Sun” American Idol Top 5 (VIDEO)

[image: Michael Becker / FOX]