Haley Reinhart took a huge risk when she chose to perform “What Is and What Should Never Be” by Led Zeppelin during the first round of the American Idol season 10 Top 3 semifinals live show on Wednesday (May 18)- watch video below.

2011 American Idol Season 10 Top 13 Finalists (Bios, Photos)

Steven Tyler loved it. Jennifer Lopez praised Haley’s performance and how she fell and moved on like a pro. Randy Jackson proclaimed Haley is in it to win it, saying she was fearless and that was one of her best performances ever.

Haley killed it! Her dad was actually playing the guitar. Amazing performance! Haley fell on the stage and continued singing like nothing happened. Those were some killer heels, but she nailed it. Haley clearly beat Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina to win the first round.

Haley Reinhart “What Is and What Should Never Be” American Idol Top 3 Video

American Idol Season 10 Top 3 Semifinals Performances
Scotty McCreery “Amazed” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “Wild One” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “What Is and What Should Never Be” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “Are You Going To Kiss Me Or Not” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “If I Die Young” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “Rhiannon” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Scotty McCreery “She Believes In Me” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Lauren Alaina “I Hope You Dance” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)
Haley Reinhart “You Oughta Know” American Idol Top 3 (VIDEO)

[image: Michael Becker / FOX]